New Research: Extractive industries and poverty: A review of recent findings and linkage mechanisms

A meta-study on the connection between poverty and mining comes out particularly depressing, "we find industrial mining to be more frequently associated with poverty exacerbation".

Extractive industries and poverty: A review of recent findings and linkage mechanisms

by Jonathan Gamu [ubc.ca], Philippe Le Billon [ubc.ac] (both Liu Institute for Global Issues, UBC) and Samuel Spiegel [ed.ac.uk] (University of Edinburgh)

Abstract

This article surveys fifty-two empirical studies on relationships between extractive industries and poverty, addressing both poverty impacts and possible linkage mechanisms. Distinguishing these studies by mode of resource extraction, we find industrial mining to be more frequently associated with poverty exacerbation, and artisanal mining with poverty reduction. Poverty exacerbation findings are more pronounced in cross-national statistical studies and ethnographic local case studies, especially when relative deprivation and longer-term impacts are taken into account; while sub-national census-based studies tend to show lower poverty levels in areas with extractive sector activities. A review of thirteen specific linkages between extractive industries and poverty highlights the importance of governance institutions and the limited effects of Corporate Social Responsibility activities. Methodologically, our survey points to the dominance of industrial mining-related data in cross-national and sub-national studies and the overlooked effects of artisanal and small-scale mining on poverty reduction at analytical scales larger than community-level. Such findings call for integrated studies assessing effects on poverty at various scales and attending to the specificities of mining-related livelihoods. Nested mixed-methods including place-based ethnographic observation, longitudinal surveys, as well as socioeconomic and political analysis across multiple scales are needed to provide more robust contextual understandings of the relationships between extractive sectors and poverty.

Read further here [sciencedirect.com].